Skip to content
Narrow screen resolution Wide screen resolution Auto adjust screen size Increase font size Decrease font size Default font size

Philosophia Verlag GmbH

Home arrow Philosophia Contributions to Philosophy arrow Aligning Natural and Positive Law: The Case of Non-Human Sentients
Info: Your browser does not accept cookies. If you want to put products into your cart and purchase them you need to enable cookies.


 


Gary Chartier

Aligning Natural and Positive Law: The Case of Non-Human Sentients


ISBN: 978-3-88405-765-0

Price: €12.80 (including 19 % tax)


Abstract

Natural law theory has many facets, including (i) the contemporary post-Thomist New Classical Natural Law (NCNL) theory and (ii) approaches that emphasize the importance of spontaneous social order. Natural law theory provides a provocative and helpful account of the moral standing of nonhuman sentients and of their status within a reasonable legal system. Where humans are concerned, natural law theorists are quite clear that what I call the Principle of Respect rules out purposeful and instrumental attacks on others’ well being; this principle could be seen to preclude attacks on animals as well as humans. What I call the Principle of Fairness might be thought to rule out arbitrary disregard for non-human sentients’ interests. Natural law theorists have not endorsed the application of these principles to non-human sentients. But the considerations that might dispose natural law theorists to acknowledge human rights should also incline them to acknowledge animal rights. Various objections to this strategy fail to convince. While it is clear how NCNL theory, if applicable, might serve to protect animal rights, the spontaneous order tradition of natural law thinking might seem to appear less relevant. 
Indeed, it might initially seem to offer no room for legal protection of non-human sentients because its focus is on human self-organization. However, social institutions that could be expected to emerge in bottom-up fashion in a free society could, indeed, offer important safeguards for animal rights.




 





new publications

Cosmetics and Makeup
Cosmetics and Makeup
€9.80
Add to Cart

The Virtue Analysis of Inner Beauty: Inner Beauty as Moral, Eudaimonistic, or Relational Virtueness
The Virtue Analysis of Inner Beauty: Inner Beauty as Moral, Eudaimonistic, or Relational Virtueness
€14.80
Add to Cart

The Beauty of Landscape
The Beauty of Landscape
€9.80
Add to Cart

Aesthetic Experience and the Experience of Poetry
Aesthetic Experience and the Experience of Poetry
€14.80
Add to Cart

An Aesthetics of Insight
An Aesthetics of Insight
€14.80
Add to Cart

The Case Against Beauty
The Case Against Beauty
€14.80
Add to Cart

The Beauty of Doing: Remarks on the Appreciation of Conceptual Art
The Beauty of Doing: Remarks on the Appreciation of Conceptual Art
€14.80
Add to Cart

The Value of Art: On Meaning and Aesthetic Experience in Difficult Modern Art
The Value of  Art: On Meaning and Aesthetic Experience in Difficult Modern Art
€9.80
Add to Cart

Art, Beauty, and Criticism
Art, Beauty, and Criticism
€9.80
Add to Cart

Beauty and Bellís Aesthetic Emotion
Beauty and Bellís Aesthetic Emotion
€14.80
Add to Cart